I had an experience recently where an individual confided in me that he was being bullied at work. There had been a number of incidents, and the last one was his final straw. He took it to HR, but they did nothing about it. His confidence had taken a hit, and he didn't know what to do. He felt uneasy in his workplace, and needed some help.
I suggested to this person that he speak to his manager. Trouble was, his manager was one of the bullies. We talked through the options he had available to him, and he decided that he needed to speak up. But as we expected, that's when things really began to get out of hand.
When he sat down with his manager to discuss how he was feeling, he was met with a swift, arrogant reply, dismissing the worker.
"That's your opinion. I'm not a bully, and neither is the other person. Stop trying to make this about everyone else. You just don't like being told what to do, that's the issue. You get defensive any time someone tries to speak to you. You need to toughen up and start listening to me, because I'm the manager."
I nearly fell off my chair when I heard this was the manager's response. What a disgraceful comment.
When he went into further detail of the incident that sparked this conversation, the manager was dismissive once more.
“That's not what happened, and I have three witnesses that will back me up too."
How convenient.
Isn't it interesting how the aggressor always has their defences and arguments ready to go, almost in anticipation of someone finally speaking up?
When I heard this was the manager's response, I was alarmed. There'll always be an element of ‘he-said, she-said’ in conflict situations; that’s just the reality of dealing with people. But how can two versions of the very same event be so vastly disproportionate? The perceptions of the events weren't just on different pages, they weren't even in the same book.
In my experiences, when a person is particularly defensive and sure of themselves in a situation like that, there's generally something to hide.
There was an excuse at every turn, almost as if the manager had been preparing herself for some backlash. She contradicted herself on a number of occasions, and even implied that they would have to cease employment with this person "if he kept causing problems."
The worker spoke to me after his conversation, and questioned whether he had done the right thing by raising the issues. He was now scared for his job.
But I reminded him, this is what manipulators do. Unfair dismissal and adverse action aside, this is what bullies do. They make you feel like you're in the wrong, and they make you feel like you're at fault. They’ll go on the attack, and suddenly you'll feel like you're to blame for their behaviour. They’ll make you feel like the perpetrator.
But remember, the bullies and the manipulators are the ones at fault, not you.